Discussion about this post

User's avatar
niko's avatar

Just some bare comments that barely begin to get into issues and angles.

Based on my own random surveys and anecdotal cases, I'm not sure how many even want an egalitarian society, short of being willing to work for it. Whoever works within the system is liable to have the system work within them. And I'd bet being in a capitalist class, dog-eat-dog set-up would produce some statistical regularities that make another virtue of vice when it comes to social Darwinist survival of the fittest. It may be false consciousness, but some ideological variant of greed is good seems all too real in both personal and historical identity formation of herd 'morality' ready to stampede over any commie conspiracy coming to America. I also wonder if what others might mean by equality amounts to a kind of live-and-let-live individualism indifferent to social relations in any root or radical sense of revolution.

Even if systematic polling, when not rigged for results, were to find majority support for a more egalitarian society, that's a what, not a why (reflecting opinion polls' primary purpose as a means of population management and manipulation). Once one dives beneath the surface, there's the rub of all sorts of reasons and motivations in the depths of us (though AI waits in the wings to know us better than we know ourselves once we're assimilated into the Borg). And not necessarily reconciliable or compatible, just in ourselves alone, let alone when we relate with others. What do we really mean by equality, not only theoretically, but practically in the ways we live? I've come across too many who talk but don't walk a path of respect for others regardless of rank, hardly being the change they say they want to see in the world.

Like you've noted elsewhere, making revolution is not a paid profession (except for impostors in academic armchairs). Let's say enough people beat the odds against us, beaten down by 'the way things are', and organize for some sort of alternative to the systemic abuse. That's when difficulties mount all the more in fleshing out some unity from diversity, and in political practice of direct democracy that seems near extinction, I'm afraid.

How do we, for example, get past checklists for political correctness, from right to left of the propaganda system of manufactured consent and dissent? Like Marx said, I'm no Marxist. But I don't find Marx himself guilty of all you accuse him. How would that play out? And skipping over whys myself, I'll simply state I'm of the opinion that BLM is controlled opposition, convid was/is psywar to launch a new world (dis)order of biogitial slavery and depopulation, global warming ('climate change') is hot air pseudoscience, trans/gender ideology is hostile to humanity, particularly women and children, and I'm neither left nor right when it comes to basic human freedom and dignity in what I'd too like to see as a more egalitarian society, or at least a society where it's a little easier to be good.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?